Supplier selection and supplier evaluation

The purchase of the various and services may only take place from approved suppliers. Purchasing will only take place if a purchasing contract has been drawn up with this (either from the supplier or our own purchasing conditions) or the has been completed. This applies to products and services.

Supplier Approval

For various reasons, the decision may be made to replace a current supplier or to look for a new supplier. Often a trial order is placed first to be able to assess the of the products. There is also the
possibility of auditing the new supplier. However, this depends on the supplier and the products/services they will provide.

When hiring a new supplier, consideration is given to, among other things:

  • Price-performance ratio;
  • Delivery reliability;
  • “Name in the market”;
  • Known reliability;
  • Dealer or producer.

When the decision is made to purchase from a new supplier, prior documents (if applicable) are required:

  • Purchase Contract;
  • Manufacturer's name;
  • Required specifications;
  • Statements comply with laws and nominal quantity;
  • of raw material/product hazards;
  • Research reports in advance or with deliveries;
  • Any copies of permits (including waste);
  • Statements of expertise (certificate, maintenance, knowledge provision).

The first deliveries are closely monitored to assess whether the agreements made are met and/or the quality, and price used are in accordance with agreements. After approval (after trial deliveries) the supplier is included in the accepted list. A product supplier will only be approved with GFSI certification or an on-site that looks at product safety, HACCP, GMP (good manufacturing practices), and traceability. This audit must be carried out by an experienced and demonstrably competent product safety auditor, with EU approval also being sufficient if all audit reports are available. In case of outsourced production or activities, a GFSI approval shall be renewed annually, and/or the above-mentioned on-site audit shall be performed annually. In these activities, test protocols should also be drawn up for the outsourced work regarding visual, chemical, and/or microbiological parameters.

It is checked whether the purchased product or outsourced process falls within the scope of the GFSI certificate. For a low-risk supplier, a completed questionnaire and a traceability test are sufficient. This questionnaire and traceability test must be renewed every 3 years. In addition, the supplier must report any significant changes in advance (statement included in the questionnaire). If products (including primary packaging) are purchased via a trader, then this trader should be GFSI certified, for , BRC . If this is not the case, the producer of the product must be approved via the same system as if he were a direct supplier. So via an audit or completed questionnaire and a traceability test.

In the case of that fall under “bulk commodity” or “agricultural products”, product testing (e.g. MRL) may suffice to ensure product safety and quality. It may be necessary in exceptional situations to purchase products from an unknown supplier. This situation can and should only occur with suppliers of products or services that cannot be directly related to the safety or quality of our products. In all other cases, the required data must be available in advance (a risk analysis must be carried out).

Required data

If applicable, must be present prior to delivery:

  • The specifications must be up to date, correct and comply with current requirements.
  • Statements regarding GMOs.
  • Statements that the potential hazards must be controlled.
  • Statements of trained personnel (cleaning, pest control, maintenance, etc.).
  • Analysis certificates/COA.
  • Permits (e.g. waste).
  • Declarations/specifications of suitability for foodstuffs.
  • Contracts with responsibilities and authority of external experts hired for , implementation or assessment of food safety system.


If there are any changes in the production process and/or recipe, our supplier must inform us. Changes that directly affect food safety and product characteristics must be communicated in advance. When changes occur in our due to -specific requirements, these customer-specific requirements have to be communicated and recorded with the supplier. All changes in contracts must be communicated in advance and signed by both parties.


Of all the products delivered, it is known by which supplier they were delivered. This is partly from a traceability point of view.

Supplier Assessment

A supplier assessment is prepared each year. The purpose of this assessment is to determine how our suppliers are “doing” and whether we believe changes must be done. The supplier assessment covers products but also services (maintenance, cleaning, pest control, research, etc.).

Suppliers who supply a product or service on a regular basis (at least 1 x 12 months or on a contract basis) are assessed. Where relevant, concrete data and interviews with the relevant buyer/department are used for the assessment.
Where relevant, concrete data and interviews with the relevant buyer/department are used for the assessment. The inputs used for the assessment include:

  • Complaints;
  • Errors;
  • Billing;
  • Keeping appointments;
  • Support if requested;
  • Provision of ;
  • Microbiological testing;
  • Experience with the products internally and by customers;
  • Reliability;
  • Cooperation in any audits;
  • Controlling hazards regarding
  • Cross ;
  • ;
  • Microbiological contamination;
  • Chemical contamination.
  • (food fraud);
  • High/low risk profile (based on the above points).

A report is made of this data. If a supplier has a shortcoming, it must be solved. If a supplier does not meet expectations in such a way that the trust is gone, the purchase of products is stopped. The suppliers with a shortcoming receive a letter. A written response is expected in return.

Standards for a supplier assessment

Standards AssessmentABCD
Number of complaints*0-55-1010-15>15
Number of errors deliveries0-55-1010-15>15
Keeping appointments (number of comments)none12>2
Support (number of comments)none12>2
Microbiological * (rejections)12-34-5>5
Experience with the
products internally and by customers (number of comments)
Reliability (number of observations)none12>2
Hazard control (number of observations)none12>2
Product Authenticitynonenonenone≥ 1

complaints/micro research in relation to food safety always

The lowest score determines the rating:

A suppliers → no action required.
B suppliers → additional checks
during ½ year on mentioned assessment points (must be A otherwise letter
C suppliers → improvements required from
supplier to be on A-B level.

D supplier -> no more purchase possible until everything has improved.

TwitterFacebookLinkedInPin It

Related articles to Is there an example: supplier reviews

Many customers and visitors to this page 'Is there an example: supplier reviews' also viewed the articles and manuals listed below:

We are a Food Tech firm in Food Safety Compliance. Experts in setting up and maintaining Food Safety Systems for companies in the Food Supply Chain. We are dedicated to breaking down the barriers for Transparency and Trust in the Global Food Supply Chain.
In our Partnership Program we would like to work together with (Non)Governmental Organizations, Universities, Multinationals and Food companies.

iMIS Food is a fully equipped Food Safety Compliance platform. Unique is the installation of an iMIS Food server at the Food company, for online and offline availability. The online (no travel costs) iMIS Food implementation process includes 6 to 10 days of support and has a lead time of 3 months.

Monthly iMIS Food Update

Would you also like to receive the monthly iMIS Food Update and be invited to our events? Then please fill in this form.

Food Safety news 7-2024

Food Safety Compliance scorecard

Online Food Safety Compliance Scorecard

Do you have any idea how the Food Safety Culture in your company is performing? Calculate now and score your company in the new tab.

BioFach visit 2022: International Organic Fair

In July, QAssurance employees Andrada Mierlut and Nele Adade visited the BioFach in Nürnberg for networking purposes and supporting nuTIQ at the fair.

Reimagining economic growth in Africa  

Read the following summary article based on the report from the “McKinsey Global Institute” on how to boost economic growth in Africa.